All insights

Hiring strategy

Fractional recruiting vs. agency: when each one makes sense

By Kelly Robinson · June 2, 2026 · 5 min read

Agencies charge per hire. Fractional teams charge for time. The right choice depends on how many roles you have, how fast they change, and who you want owning the process.

Most growing companies hit the same wall. There are six open roles, the hiring managers are frustrated, the internal recruiter (if there is one) is drowning, and someone suggests "let's just use an agency." Sometimes that is exactly right. Often it isn't. Here is how we think about the choice.

What an agency is built for

A contingent agency is paid a percentage of first-year salary when a candidate starts. That model is great when you have one or two roles, you need them filled quickly, and you don't want to think about process. The agency carries the risk, and you only pay when someone shows up.

The trade-off is incentives. Agencies make money when a hire happens, not when the right hire happens. They also work several clients at once, so your role competes for attention with everyone else's. And at 20 to 25 percent of salary per hire, costs balloon fast when you have more than a handful of openings.

What fractional recruiting is built for

Fractional recruiting (you will also hear it called RPO or embedded recruiting) flips the model. You pay a flat monthly fee for a recruiter or recruiting team that works inside your company, part-time or full-time, for as long as you need them. They use your applicant tracking system, join your hiring manager meetings, and carry your employer brand into every conversation.

Because the fee does not change with each hire, the incentive is to fill roles well and build a process that keeps working after we scale down. It is the right fit when you have three or more open roles at a time, when hiring comes in waves, or when you want a real process without the overhead of a permanent talent team.

A simple way to decide

  • One or two roles a year, no internal recruiting function: a contingent agency or a retained search is usually the most efficient path.
  • A critical leadership or hard-to-fill specialist role: retained search, where one team gives it their full attention.
  • Three or more open roles at a time, or hiring that comes in bursts: fractional recruiting. The math on a flat monthly fee wins quickly.
  • Hourly or project-based needs: staffing, billed by the hour, with compliance and payroll handled for you.

The question that matters most

Who do you want owning your hiring process? If the answer is "someone else, just send me candidates," an agency is fine. If the answer is "us, but we need experienced hands to build and run it," that is fractional recruiting. PKR's tagline, "here when you're slammed, gone when you're not," is really a description of that second model.

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upHow we use AI in hiring (and where we deliberately don't)