All insights

Hiring strategy

Skills-based hiring, done honestly

By Kelly Robinson · September 8, 2026 · 6 min read

Share LinkedIn

Dropping the degree requirement is the easy part. Actually hiring for skills means changing how you screen, interview and decide. Here is what that looks like in practice.

Shanah tovah to our readers observing Rosh Hashanah, which begins at sundown on Friday, September 11. We also pause this week to remember September 11 and everyone whose lives were changed that day.

Over the past few years a long list of employers announced they were moving to skills-based hiring and dropping degree requirements. It was the right instinct. But when researchers at Harvard Business School and the Burning Glass Institute went back to check, they found that at most of those companies the share of hires without degrees had barely moved. The posting changed. The hiring did not.

That gap is the whole subject of this piece. Here is what has to change for skills-based hiring to be real.

1. Define the skill as something you can see

"Strong communicator" is not a skill, it is an adjective. "Can explain a technical trade-off to a non-technical stakeholder and get a decision" is a skill, because you can watch for it. Go through the scorecard and rewrite every competency until it describes an observable behavior. If you cannot describe what the evidence would look like, you cannot hire for it.

2. Replace the proxy with evidence

  • A degree, a brand-name employer or a title is a proxy. It tells you someone else once judged this person worthy. Decide what that proxy was standing in for, then test for the real thing.
  • A short, paid work sample, ideally under two hours and close to the actual job, is the single most useful replacement. Keep it realistic and the same for every finalist.
  • Structured interview questions tied to each competency, with a scoring guide, are the second. "Tell me about a time" questions work when you know in advance what a strong answer contains.
  • Reference calls built on the same competencies are the third. Ask the referee for an example of the skill, not for a character reference.

3. Fix the screen, not just the posting

Most resumes are filtered before a person reads them. If your applicant tracking system or your recruiter's habits still sort by school and employer, the degree line you deleted is still doing its work invisibly. Review the knockout questions and the shortlist criteria, and make sure they match the scorecard rather than the old profile.

4. Watch the final decision

This is where skills-based hiring usually dies. Two finalists score about the same, the hiring manager picks the one with the familiar background, and everyone agrees it was "a judgment call." Make the tie-breaker explicit in advance: the work sample, or the hardest competency. Then hold to it.

5. Measure it

Twice a year, look at who was hired, where they came from and how they are performing at six and twelve months. If the profile of your hires has not changed, the process has not changed either, whatever the postings say. If it has, and performance is holding, you have widened your talent pool without lowering the bar. That is the whole point.

At PKR we build every search on a scorecard of observable competencies, and we test for them directly. Skills-based hiring, done honestly, is mostly just good hiring with the proxies removed.

Share LinkedIn

Sources & further reading

  1. Harvard Business Review — Skills-Based Hiring Is on the Rise (Fuller, Langer, Sigelman)
  2. Burning Glass Institute — Skills-Based Hiring: The Long Road from Pronouncements to Practice (with Harvard Business School)
  3. Harvard Business School, Managing the Future of Work — skills-based hiring research
  4. Opportunity@Work — research on workers Skilled Through Alternative Routes (STARs)
  5. Schmidt & Hunter — The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology (Psychological Bulletin, 1998)

Was this useful?

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upHow many interviews is enough?