All insights

Hiring strategy

Silver medalists: the candidates you didn't hire are your fastest Q1 pipeline

By Kelly Robinson · November 17, 2026 · 4 min read

Share LinkedIn

Every search produces one hire and several strong people you turned down. Most companies never speak to them again. Here is how a short thank-you now becomes a January hire later.

Thanksgiving in the United States is next Thursday, November 26, so this is the last full working week for many of our readers before the holiday. We are grateful for every one of you. Expect slower replies next week, from us and from your candidates.

Think about your last search. One person was hired. Two or three others reached the final round, impressed the panel, and lost on a close call. You sent them a form rejection, or nothing, and moved on. Those people are the fastest, cheapest pipeline you will ever have, and most companies let them walk out the door.

With Thanksgiving a week away, this is a good week to fix that, and to say thank you while you do.

Why silver medalists matter

  • They are already vetted. They passed your screen, your structured interviews and your scorecard. The expensive part is done.
  • They know your company and were interested enough to go the distance. Half the selling is done too.
  • The person you hired may not work out, or a second seat may open in January. The runner-up is a two-week hire instead of a two-month search.
  • How you treat them is a public signal. Finalists talk about their experience, and a gracious no is remembered for years.

What to do this week

  • Send every finalist from this year a personal note. Not a template. One specific thing you appreciated about them, a sentence of honest feedback, and genuine thanks for their time.
  • For the ones you would hire tomorrow, ask: "Would you be open to hearing from us about future roles?" Nearly everyone says yes.
  • Log them against the scorecard. Which competencies did they excel at? What role would they fit? Where did the close call land? This turns a name into a usable record.
  • Put a check-in on the calendar for February. A short, no-ask note keeps the relationship alive.

What to do in January

When the new role opens, call the silver medalists first, before the posting goes live. A search that starts with three warm, pre-vetted, interested finalists finishes in weeks, not months. We run this on every PKR search, and it is a large part of why our clients fill roles about 25 percent faster than the national average.

A broader thank-you

Gratitude is not soft. It is one of the most practical tools in hiring: it keeps candidates warm, keeps clients loyal and keeps teams together. So to the hiring managers who gave us their kickoff hour, the candidates who trusted us with their next move, and the readers who reply to these notes every week: thank you. Happy Thanksgiving.

Share LinkedIn

Sources & further reading

  1. SHRM — Talent pipeline and candidate relationship research
  2. Harvard Business Review — Your Approach to Hiring Is All Wrong (Peter Cappelli)
  3. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey
  4. PKR Insights — Candidate experience is your employer brand
  5. PKR Recruiting client results (internal data, 2024–2026)

Was this useful?

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upHiring veterans: translating military experience into your scorecard