All insights

Process

Write the scorecard before you post the role

By Kelly Robinson · July 14, 2026 · 4 min read

Share LinkedIn

Most hiring debates happen because nobody agreed what "strong" meant before the first interview. A one-page scorecard fixes that, and makes every interview fairer and faster.

Ask five interviewers after a loop what they were looking for and you will get five answers. That is not a people problem. It is a planning problem. The single highest-leverage hour in any search is the one spent writing the scorecard before the role goes live.

What a scorecard is (and isn't)

It is one page. It lists the five competencies that matter most for this specific role, and for each one a plain-English description of what good looks like, plus one or two interview questions that surface it. It is not the job description, and it is not a list of twenty nice-to-haves.

Why it works

  • Everyone scores the same things, so debriefs compare evidence instead of impressions.
  • Structured interviews, where every candidate is asked comparable questions and rated against set criteria, are among the strongest predictors of job performance in the personnel-selection research, and far stronger than unstructured conversations.
  • It is fairer. Candidates are judged on the role, not on who they happened to remind an interviewer of.
  • It is faster. When the criteria are agreed up front, a decision takes a 15-minute debrief, not two weeks of back-and-forth.

How to write one in an hour

  • Ask the hiring manager: what will this person have achieved at 90 days and at one year? Work backwards to the competencies that make that possible.
  • Pick five. If you have eight, you have not prioritized.
  • For each, write one sentence describing a strong answer and one describing a weak one. That sentence is what interviewers will score against.
  • Assign each competency to one interviewer so nothing is covered three times and nothing is missed.

We write a scorecard for every role we touch at PKR, and it is one of the reasons our clients fill roles faster without lowering the bar. Our one-page template is below. Print it, fill in the five rows with your hiring team, and hand a copy to every interviewer before the first conversation.

Share LinkedIn

Sources & further reading

  1. Schmidt & Hunter — The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology (Psychological Bulletin, 1998)
  2. Harvard Business Review — Your Approach to Hiring Is All Wrong (Peter Cappelli)
  3. PKR Recruiting client results (internal data, 2024–2026)

Was this useful?

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upThe real cost of a slow hire (and how to cut time-to-fill without lowering the bar)