Interviewing
Reference checks that actually tell you something
By Kelly Robinson · July 28, 2026 · 5 min read

Most reference calls confirm a start date and a job title. Run them like a structured interview and they become the cheapest risk check in your whole process.
To our readers across the Caribbean, happy Emancipation Day (August 1), a day of remembrance and freedom. And to our Swiss friends, happy National Day on the same date. If you are off this week, this one will keep.
Here is how most reference checks go. A recruiter calls the two names the candidate supplied, hears that they were "great to work with," asks whether the referee would rehire them, writes down "yes," and the offer goes out. Nobody learned anything, and the whole exercise took longer than it was worth.
That is a shame, because a reference call is the only point in your process where you talk to someone who has actually watched the candidate do the job. Done well, it is the cheapest risk check you have.
Why the usual call fails
- The candidate picked the referee. Of course the feedback is warm.
- The questions are about personality ("what are they like?") instead of performance on the things that matter for your role.
- There is no structure, so you cannot compare what two referees said about two finalists.
- The research is clear that unstructured reference checks are weak predictors of performance on their own. Structure is what gives them value.
Run it like a structured interview
Start from the scorecard you wrote before the role was posted. If you do not have one, that is the first fix, and our one-page template is linked below. Then build the call around it.
- Set the frame. "We are seriously considering [name] for a role where X, Y and Z matter most. I would love your honest view on each." Honest people relax when you tell them what you are actually trying to learn.
- Ask for examples, not adjectives. "Tell me about a time they had to [competency]." Then stay quiet. A strong referee gives you a story in ten seconds. A hesitation is information.
- Ask the development question. "What did they need from you as a manager to do their best work?" Nobody is perfect, and this question gets a truthful answer without asking anyone to badmouth a colleague. It also tells you how to onboard them.
- Ask about scope. "How big was the team, budget, or book they owned?" Titles inflate. Scope does not.
- Use the same five questions for every finalist. That is what makes the answers comparable, and it is what keeps the process fair.
Keep it clean
- Only ask job-related questions. Steer away from anything touching health, family, age or other protected characteristics, even in small talk.
- If a third-party vendor runs background or reference checks for you, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies: written notice, consent and an adverse-action process if the result changes your decision.
- Get the candidate's permission before calling a current employer. Most finalists are still employed.
At PKR we run references for every placement, and the development question alone has reshaped more than one onboarding plan. It takes fifteen minutes per referee. It is the best fifteen minutes in the process.
Need the scorecard first?
Download the one-page hiring scorecard (PDF)Sources & further reading
- SHRM — Conducting Background Investigations and Reference Checks (toolkit)
- U.S. EEOC — Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know
- U.S. FTC — Using Consumer Reports: What Employers Need to Know (FCRA)
- Schmidt & Hunter — The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology (Psychological Bulletin, 1998)
- Harvard Business Review — The Right Way to Check Someone's References
Was this useful?
Want to talk this through for your team?
A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.
