All insights

Candidate experience

Interviewing with care: a humane process is also a better one

By Kelly Robinson · October 6, 2026 · 5 min read

Share LinkedIn

Burnout is high, and your interview process is often a candidate's first look at how your company treats people. Here is how to run a loop that is rigorous and kind, and why the two go together.

October 10 is World Mental Health Day, a good week to check in on your team and yourself. Monday, October 12 is Indigenous Peoples' Day in the United States, a day to honor the Native peoples whose lands we live and work on, and Thanksgiving in Canada. Happy Thanksgiving to our Canadian readers.

The World Health Organization estimates that depression and anxiety cost the global economy around twelve billion working days a year, and Gallup's global workplace research continues to find a large share of employees reporting daily stress. Your candidates are those employees. They are interviewing with you while burned out, while holding down the job they have, and while quietly worried about the whole thing.

That matters for two reasons. The first is simple decency. The second is that the interview process is the clearest preview a candidate ever gets of how your company treats people, and they are drawing conclusions from it. The good news is that the humane version of a process and the effective version are the same process.

Remove the uncertainty

  • In the first conversation, describe the whole path: how many steps, roughly how long, who they will meet and what each conversation covers. Not knowing is the stressor, not the interview itself.
  • Share the topics in advance. You learn more from a prepared candidate than an ambushed one, and candidates who have had time to think give you better evidence to score.
  • Give a date for the decision and keep it. If it slips, say so before the date passes.

Respect their time and their current job

  • Offer early and late slots. Most candidates are employed, and taking four calls from a parking lot is a quiet indignity.
  • Stack interviews into one or two sessions instead of spreading them over three weeks.
  • Four structured conversations, not seven "culture chats." Every extra round is another afternoon they have to invent an excuse for.
  • If you ask for a work sample, keep it under two hours, make it relevant, and pay for it if it is substantial.

Interview like a person

  • Open by making the candidate comfortable, not by testing whether they can handle discomfort. Nervous people underperform; you want to see their real work, not their stress response.
  • Ask the same structured questions of everyone and score against the scorecard. It is fairer, it is more predictive, and it protects candidates from the whims of whoever happens to be in the room.
  • Do not ask about health, family plans, age or anything else that is not job-related. It is unlawful in most places and it is unkind everywhere.
  • Leave real time for their questions. The ones they ask tell you what they value.

Close every loop

A clear, prompt no with a brief, honest reason is one of the kindest things a company can do, and one of the rarest. It is also protective: every candidate you ghost talks to someone, and the ones you treated well do too. Our client-side candidate satisfaction sits at 94 percent, and most of it comes from this one habit.

Rigor and kindness are not in tension. The structured, transparent, well-paced loop is both the most predictive process and the most humane one. This week, check in on your team, and then check in on your process.

Share LinkedIn

Sources & further reading

  1. World Health Organization — Mental health at work (fact sheet)
  2. Gallup — State of the Global Workplace report
  3. U.S. Surgeon General — Framework for Workplace Mental Health and Well-Being
  4. Schmidt & Hunter — The Validity and Utility of Selection Methods in Personnel Psychology (Psychological Bulletin, 1998)
  5. PKR Recruiting client and candidate results (internal data, 2024–2026)

Was this useful?

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upThe kickoff meeting: the one hour that decides how the search goes