All insights

Process

The five hiring numbers a leader should actually watch

By Kelly Robinson · October 20, 2026 · 5 min read

Share LinkedIn

Most recruiting dashboards track activity. These five numbers track outcomes: how fast, how well, and whether the people you hire stay. Here is what to measure and what good looks like.

October 24 is United Nations Day, a fitting week to be thinking about teams that work across borders. And to our readers in New Zealand, enjoy Labour Day on Monday, October 26.

Open most recruiting reports and you will find a wall of activity: candidates sourced, emails sent, calls made, interviews scheduled. It all looks like work, and it is. But none of it tells a leader the only three things they actually want to know: Are we hiring fast enough? Are we hiring well? Do the people we hire stay? Here are the five numbers that answer those questions, and what good looks like for each.

1. Time-to-fill, and time between steps

Time-to-fill is the days from a role opening to an accepted offer. National benchmarks put the average at roughly six weeks, longer for leadership and specialist roles. On its own it is a blunt number. The useful version breaks it down by stage: days from open to first interview, from first interview to final, from final to offer, from offer to acceptance. Almost all delay lives between steps, and this view shows you exactly where.

2. Pipeline conversion by stage

Of the candidates who reach a first interview, how many reach the final round? Of finalists, how many receive an offer? Healthy funnels narrow steadily. A funnel that collapses at one stage is telling you something specific: a screen that is too loose, a hiring manager who is filtering on something not in the scorecard, or a work sample that is scaring good people off. You cannot fix a funnel you cannot see.

3. Offer acceptance rate

Offers accepted divided by offers made. We look for 80 percent or better. Below that, the problem is almost never the candidates. It is a range that was not tested against the market, a process that ran so long the candidate accepted elsewhere, or a counteroffer nobody prepared for. Each declined offer deserves a one-line reason, logged, so the pattern shows.

4. Candidate satisfaction, including the people you did not hire

A two-question survey to every candidate who reached an interview: how would you rate the process, and would you apply again? The people you turn down are the majority of your candidates and the loudest voices about your employer brand. Our candidate satisfaction runs at 94 percent, and most of it comes from closing every loop promptly and honestly.

5. Twelve-month retention of new hires

Quality of hire is hard to measure directly, but one proxy is honest and cheap: how many of the people hired a year ago are still here and performing? Pair it with the 90-day check-in. If retention is weak, trace it back: was the scorecard wrong, the interview loop too loose, or the onboarding absent? Eighty-nine percent of PKR placements are still in seat after twelve months, and that number is the one we care about most.

Getting the numbers without a new system

  • A spreadsheet with one row per candidate and a date for each stage gives you numbers one through three.
  • A two-question email after the final interview gives you number four.
  • A calendar reminder at twelve months gives you number five.
  • Review all five once a quarter with the people who hire. The conversation matters more than the dashboard.

Activity is what the recruiting team does. Outcomes are what the business feels. If your recruiting partner cannot show you these five numbers for your own searches, that is worth a conversation.

Share LinkedIn

Sources & further reading

  1. SHRM — Talent Acquisition Benchmarking research (time-to-fill, cost-per-hire)
  2. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics — Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey
  3. Google re:Work — Hiring guides and measurement
  4. United Nations — United Nations Day, 24 October
  5. PKR Recruiting client and candidate results (internal data, 2024–2026)

Was this useful?

Want to talk this through for your team?

A no-pressure 30 minutes with Kelly.

Book a consultation
Next upYear-end offers: bonuses, start dates and the December negotiation